The Black & White Fallacy

Colbert has phrased his question as if he is giving us a choice. But it's not much of a choice is it? He has given us two options, and they are black and white. One of them (hating America) is obviously presented as the wrong choice. There are in fact many reasons to oppose a war: maybe you think the war is not justified, or that the country's budget would be better spent on something like education or health care, or maybe you don't want American soldiers to die fighting. Colbert is giving us a misleading choice by making it black and white.